| The report that Aisha was married at six and the marriage consummated at nine appears only in al-Bukhari.
| False | The claim that it is 'only in al-Bukhari': the report of Aisha's age is in Muslim too, through two chains
|
| In al-Umm, Imam al-Shafi'i argues from Aisha's marriage that a father may marry off his minor daughter without her consent.
| True | A father's authority to marry off his virgin daughter without her consent: Aisha's marriage at seven as the proof
|
| Imam al-Shafi'i cites Aisha's marriage at six or seven as the proof for child marriage.
| True | Fathers may give minors in marriage: Aisha's marriage at six or seven as the proof
|
| Imam al-Shafi'i ruled that a man may marry his daughter born of zina.
| Partly true | A child born of zina is not legally one's child: marrying the daughter is disliked, but not annulled
|